Hydrology and public health: linking human leptospirosis and local hydrological dynamics in Trinidad, West Indies
© Vega Corredor and Opadeyi; licensee Springer. 2014
Received: 17 April 2013
Accepted: 28 November 2013
Published: 12 February 2014
Human leptospirosis is currently one of the most widespread bacterial zoonoses and is the only epidemic-prone infection that can be transmitted directly from contaminated water. Transmission in humans is caused by direct or indirect contact with contaminated water, soil or infected urine, blood or tissue of carrier animals. Initial symptoms are similar with those suffered during influenza, dengue or viral hepatitis. As the disease progresses, internal organs can be compromised causing severe hemorrhages, organ failure and, potentially, death. Human leptospirosis is a growing global public health problem although, in endemic areas, it is considered a neglected disease. Hydrological factors, including rainfall and floods, have been frequently related to human leptospirosis. In the Caribbean, leptospirosis is endemic and it is a disease under surveillance. Based on confirmed cases, in Trinidad & Tobago the average annual incidence of human leptospirosis ranges between 1.78 to 1.84 cases per 100,000 population.
In this paper, we used Geographical Information System (GIS) analysis and Geographically Weighted Poisson Regression (GWPR) for the development of ecological models, to assess the spatial variability in the relationships between local hydrological factors and human leptospirosis occurrence at the community level on the island of Trinidad. Five explanatory covariates were developed for the analysis: rainfall, river drainage density, proportion of soil with free drainage, proportion of soil with imperfect/impeded drainage, and a topographic wetness index.
The GWPR model presented an improvement (AICc = 392.46; deviance = 583.36) over the Global regression model (AICc = 595.52; deviance = 381.78), indicating spatial variability in the relationship of human leptospirosis and hydrological factors. Pseudo t-values of rainfall, imperfect/impeded drainage soil and the topographic wetness index showed high values (|t| >1.96) indicating that local relationships with leptospirosis occurrence may be significant.
Results suggest that rainfall, imperfect/impeded drainage soil and topographic wetness index influence the local dynamics of human leptospirosis.
KeywordsHuman leptospirosis Zoonosis Waterborne disease Neglected disease Geographically Weighted Poisson Regression Spatial heterogeneity Spatial analysis
Human leptospirosis is a waterborne disease caused by spirochetes of the genus Leptospira. Currently, it is considered the most common widespread bacterial zoonosis and a growing worldwide public health problem (Adler & de la Peña Monctezuma 2010; Levett 2001). Leptospirosis is a disease with a very complex ecology involving the bacteria, the animal reservoirs, humans and their surrounding environment. Pathogenic leptospires are transmitted to humans by direct or indirect contact with infected urine, blood or tissue of carrier animals or urine-contaminated water, soil or food (Bharti et al. 2003; World Health Organization 2003; Caribbean Epidemiology Center 1999). The sources of contamination are commonly rats, but domestic or wild animals also can be carriers of the pathogenic bacteria (Lau et al. 2010a). Leptospirosis is considered the only epidemic-prone infection that can be transmitted to humans directly from contaminated water, damp soil, crop vegetation or mud, through cuts, abrasions, mucous membranes or wet skin (Levett 2001; Watson et al. 2007). In the humid tropics and subtropics, where the disease has a high impact, climatic and environmental factors such as rainfall, floods, land cover and land cover change have been related to the occurrence of leptospirosis (Bharti et al. 2003; World Health Organization 2003; Lau et al. 2010b). Initially, leptospirosis symptoms can be similar to those caused by flu but, as the disease progresses, internal organs can be compromised causing severe hemorrhages (e.g.Weil’s disease), organ failure and, potentially, death (Vinetz et al. 2005).
Outbreaks have been reported from many regions around the world, including: Italy, 1994, (Beniamino et al. 1987) Nicaragua, 1995 (Zaki & Shieh 1996), Brazil, 1996 (Barcellos & Sabroza 2001), Russian Federation, 1997 (Kalashnikov et al. 2003), Honduras, 1998 (Naranjo et al. 2008), India, 1997, 1999, 2002 (Vijayachari et al. 2003; Sehgal et al. 2002; Jena et al. 2004), Australia, 1999 (Smythe et al. 2002) Hawaii, 2004 (Gaynor et al. 2007), Guyana, 2005 (Dechet et al. 2012), the U.S., 2005 (Stern et al. 2010) and the Philippines, 2009 (Amilasan et al. 2009). Besides being associated to floods following heavy rains during the rainy season, or floods which occur in areas affected by either tropical cyclones or land use/land cover changes (Vinetz et al. 2005; Mahajan & Chlabra 2008), outbreaks have been reported after occupational or recreational activities related to water such as fishing, farming, canoeing, fresh water swimming or bathing (Keith 1996; Sanders et al. 1999; Sejvar et al. 2003; Segura et al. 2005; Vanasco et al. 2008). Leptospirosis affects rural and urban areas (including slum settlements) irrespectively, and avoiding exposure to the disease can be difficult for populations living nearby environmental sources of contamination, particularly those which are frequently affected by heavy rainfall and floods (Maciel et al. 2008).
Incidence rates range from 0.1 - 1 per 100,000 population per year in temperate zones and as high as 10–100 per 100,000 population per year or more in the tropics (World Health Organization 2003). Even though it is distributed worldwide, human leptospirosis is considered a neglected disease (Michel et al. 2002; World Health Organization 2011). Often, the lack of awareness about the scope of this public health threat among populations at risk leads to underreporting and misdiagnosis of cases (World Health Organization 2003). Viral hepatitis, influenza, malaria and, in particular, dengue are the conditions with which leptospirosis is more frequently misdiagnosed. Furthermore, in less developed countries, it is poorly recognized and laboratory diagnosis is less likely to happen due to a lack of appropriate testing equipment or the difficulty in processing samples to completion (Adler & de la Peña Monctezuma 2010; Lau et al. 2010a).
In the Caribbean, human leptospirosis is endemic and a disease under surveillance. Between 1980 and 2005 a total of 12,475 cases of were reported from all Caribbean countries, with 2,370 (19%) of these corresponding to Trinidad & Tobago. In the last few years, Jamaica and Guyana have been the countries reporting the majority of cases throughout the region (Caribbean Epidemiology Center 2009; Caribbean Epidemiology Center 2010; Caribbean Epidemiology Center 2011). In Trinidad & Tobago, the average annual incidence rate reported is 1.84 per 100,000 population (Mohan et al. 2009). In this country the disease is considered underreported and awareness regarding its existence among the population is limited. Consequently, the public health importance attached to this zoonosis is low, particularly when compared to other conditions such dengue or dengue hemorrhagic fever (Mohan et al. 2009).
With a projected increase in the frequency of natural hazards related to severe weather, such as floods resulting from intense precipitation (De et al. 2005; Min et al. 2011), combined with increasing anthropogenic changes to the environment such as urbanization or the establishment of informal settlements, it is likely that new suitable environments for leptospirosis propagation will be opened (Vinetz et al. 2005), increasing the risk for people to contract the disease. Small island developing states such as Trinidad & Tobago can be at particular risk: their small size, vulnerable ecosystems, limited natural and financial resources and inadequate infrastructure make these countries susceptible to the effects of natural disasters (Lau et al. 2010b) and, as a result, potentially suitable environments for leptospirosis transmission and propagation.
Much remains to be understood about the role of environmental factors (hydrological in particular) on leptospirosis dynamics and how these can vary from one location to another. There is a clear need for multidisciplinary studies to help to understand the complex ecology and epidemiology of this disease, as well as the different mechanisms of non-biomedical factors influencing its occurrence (World Health Organization 2003; Lau et al. 2010b; Wilcox & Colwell 2005). In the last few decades, GIS analysis and spatial statistics have been more frequently used for the development of ecological analyses of diseases. This has allowed the introduction of new approaches towards more suitable ways to explore disease spatial patterns as well as the intricate dynamics of disease determinants (Waller & Gotway 2004; Lau et al. 2012). In this paper, GIS analysis and Geographically Weighted Poisson Regression (GWPR) (Nakaya et al. 2005) were used for the development of ecological models to explore and analyze spatial variations in relationships between local hydrological factors and leptospirosis occurrence. Following previous research which has linked leptospirosis with hydrological events such as floods and heavy rainfall e.g. (Lau et al. 2010b; Barcellos & Sabroza 2001; Gaynor et al. 2007; Dechet et al. 2012; Amilasan et al. 2009), we present a multidisciplinary approach towards the quantitative analysis, assessment, modeling and mapping of the risk of leptospirosis in Trinidad at the community level, as it relates to hydrological factors. We explored the existence of spatial variation in human leptospirosis patterns and the existence of spatial heterogeneity in its relationship with local hydrological factors. Thus, we tested the hypothesis that spatial heterogeneity exists in these relationships.
Data of leptospirosis cases used in this study were obtained with the permission of the Trinidad & Tobago Ministry of Health (MoH), under condition to keep private all personal information contained in the files. All data were retrieved from the National Surveillance Unit (NSU) of the MoH. Two types of leptospirosis data cases are collected by the health authorities in Trinidad: (i) reported cases, which have been clinically diagnosed as being suspicious of leptospirosis; and (ii) confirmed cases which have been confirmed by laboratory testing. In the NSU archives, 1,545 reported cases were found between 2001 and 2008, and 250 confirmed leptospirosis cases from 1998 to 2008. In this paper, only confirmed cases (CC) were used for models development. From these data, annual incidence of leptospirosis (cases per 100,000 population) was calculated (Figure 2b) as well as the mean and standard deviation of monthly leptospirosis incidence (Figure 2c). The relationship between monthly rainfall and incidence is shown in Figure 2d.
Here, P i refers to the population of each of n total communities, obtained from the Trinidad census of 2000. The expected number of cases (E i ) was used to generate a kernel map and further Geographically Weighted Poisson Regression (GWPR) models.
where is the predicted intercept parameter at geographical location, u i (a vector of x,y map co-ordinates,u xi , u yi ), for community i, w ij are the geographical weights for the each j predicted locations. Following Equation 3, local estimates of disease ratio were transformed into geographically weighted disease ratios. These ratios correspond to the ratio of the kernel density of observed leptospirosis CC to the kernel density of expected cases (Nakaya et al. 2005), and were used as a means to identify areas where leptospirosis cases were generally higher or lower than expected.
Hydrological covariates development
Summary of covariates, data sources and processing methods
Community average annual rainfall (mm/year)
Isohyetal maps of mean annual rainfall in Trinidad from 1961–1990, 1991, 1999, 2000, 2001 and 2002 (Trinidad & Tobago Meteorological Office).
1. Isohyetal maps georectified and digitized to produce vector lines of equal mean annual rainfall.
2. Vector lines were interpolated onto a raster grid using a natural neighbor method and the statistical mean across years was then calculated using a weighted average.
3. Mean annual total rainfall for each community was then extracted (Figure 4a).
Proportion of soil with free (SOILFREE) or imperfect/impeded (SOILIMPD) drainage in each community (% area)
1. Codes of dominant soils in the island were extracted from the soils map and, from these, soil and drainage type were identified (free draining, imperfect/impeded drainage).
Average river density by community (m/ha)
1:25,000 vector line data of rivers in Trinidad.
1. Using vector overlay, river vectors were split at the community borders and assigned community codes.
2. The vector length of each river segment was calculated and the total length of the segments was summarized by community.
3. Finally, the river drainage density for each community (average river length per hectare) was calculated by dividing the total river length in each community by the community area (Figure 4d).
Average wetness index by community, In (α/tan S0)
Raster Digital Elevation Model (DEM) derived from photogrammetry and processed to remove topographic “sinks”.
1. Upslope flow accumulation (α) and local topographic slope (S0) in degrees were calculated in GIS.
2. Wetness index was then derived for each pixel using a map algebra calculation of In (α/tan S0).
3. The average topographic wetness index for each community was then extracted (Figure 4e).
Mean annual rainfall (RAINMEAN)
Soils drainage characteristics (SOILFREE and SOILIMPD)
Composition of the soils and their drainage characteristics may be important factors which influence leptospirosis incidence. Previous studies have found association between pathogenic leptospirosis and soils with high moisture and organic matter content (Mohan et al. 2009; Henry & Johnson 1978). Recently, it has been demonstrated that on dry days leptospires survive in wet soils and then, on rainy days, they emerge into surface water (Saito et al. 2013). Based on this, soils may be considered to be a likely reservoir of leptospires in the environment and a relevant factor in the disease transmission. In addition, soil drainage can influence the likelihood of surface water ponding after rainfall. In this study, soil drainage data in Trinidad were analyzed (Table 1). Maps presenting percentage area of soil with free drainage (SOILFREE) and percentage area of soil with imperfect/impeded drainage (SOILIMPD) for each community are shown in Figure 4b and c respectively.
Average river density (RIVRDENS)
Pathogenic leptospires have been found to be associated to water bodies such as streams, lakes or springs (Henry & Johnson 1978) and it may be possible that areas with a high density of these features can be at higher risk of leptospirosis occurrence. In addition, high river density may indicate areas that are relatively wet thereby, areas at potential risk. Table 1 summarizes data and methods used to calculate river density in Trinidad for each community. Average river density for each community in Trinidad is presented in Figure 4d.
Topographic wetness index (WETINDEX), In (α/tan S0)
where, α is the upslope flow accumulation and S0 is the local topographic slope in degrees. A high wetness index exists where there is a combination of low slope and high flow accumulation (Beven & Kirby 1979; Quinn et al. 1995), thus areas at greater likelihood for wetness are indicated. Methods used to obtain the parameters described above and, to calculate the topographic wetness index are explained in Table 1. The average topographic wetness index for each community calculated is presented in Figure 4e.
Global Poisson Regression (GPR) and Geographically Weighted Poisson Regression (GWPR)
In order to examine the spatial variation in the relationships between local hydrological factors and leptospirosis across the communities of Trinidad, non-parametric global Poisson regression (GPR) and Geographically Weighted Poisson Regression (GWPR) models were developed. GWPR methodology was adopted in accordance with the characteristic of the leptospirosis data which, due to the low numbers included in the observed counts, were expected to follow a Poisson distribution (Lovett & Flowerdew 1989).
Prior to running GPR and GWPR models, a test for multicollinearity among covariates was developed using matrix condition numbers, within the spatial statistics toolbox of ArcGIS. Multicollinearity is a situation where two or more explanatory covariates are highly related linearly, and can lead to unreliable model estimates. The condition test assesses multicollinearity for all predictor variables together and assigns values to each location. Values above 30 are usually taken to indicate problems with the data.
For the development of the GPR and GWPR models, observed counts of leptospirosis confirmed cases were used as the dependent (outcome) covariate, with expected cases (E i ) used as the offset variable. For independent (explanatory) covariates, average annual rainfall (RAINMEAN), the percentage coverage of free-draining soil (SOILFREE), the percentage coverage of imperfect/impeded drainage soil (SOILIMPD), community river density (RIVRDENS) and the topographic wetness index (WETINDEX) were used, the development of each of which is explained previously.
To calibrate the GWPR models, kernel regression methodology was used. Smoothed geographical variations of parameters with spatial weighting kernels (centered in u i ) were estimated and the parameter estimates calibrated in a point-wise way. To estimate GWPR parameters, the geographically weighted local likelihood principle was used (Lovett & Flowerdew 1989). The key difference between GWR and a standard kernel regression model (SKRM) is that in GWR the kernel is in geographical space and the regression model is in predictor-variable space, while in SKRM both the regression model and the kernel are defined in predictor-variable space. GWPR software provides four different kernel types for the model calibration (fixed with a Gaussian weighting function, fixed bi-square, adaptive Gaussian and adaptive bi-square). In the fixed kernel, the optimal distance away from the regression point will be found; for adaptive, the optimal number of neighbors for use in the regression will be found. To avoid large standard errors and bias in local parameter estimates (due to either few data points in a short distance or a large number of points with a long distance to the regression point i) an optimal size of bandwidth is necessary (Cheng et al. 2011). In this study, the Akaike Information Criterion with a correction for finite sample sizes (AICc) (Fotheringham et al. 2002) was used as indicator to analyze the performance or goodness of fit of the models and the performance of the bandwidth, where the model with the minimum AICc value was selected as having the optimum bandwidth. The AICc together with a fixed Gaussian kernel type and golden selection bandwidth were the GWPR indicators used to complete model calibration. Full details of both the GPW and GWPR methods used are provided by Nakaya et al. (Nakaya et al. 2005).
Where Se refers to the local standard error of the k th parameter estimate, taking in account the variation in the data (Cheng et al. 2011). Pseudo t-values follow approximately a standard normal distribution if the true regression parameter is zero and mapping them is useful for identifying spatial variations in relationships between explanatory covariates and the outcome covariate.
To compare between models, the AICc was used. Generally, the model with the lowest value of AICc should be selected as the optimum model, but a difference of smaller than 2 suggest that there is little difference in the performance of the two models.
Results and discussion
Distribution of leptospirosis in Trinidad
The average annual incidence of leptospirosis between 1998 and 2008 calculated in this study was 1.78 per 100,000 population, slightly lower than the figure of 1.84 per thousand population calculated by Mohan et al. (Mohan et al. 2009). The reason for this reduction is probably related to the difference in the data time frame used in the studies: Mohan et al. (Mohan et al. 2009) analyzed data from 1996 to 2007, and here we analyzed data from 1998 to 2008. The annual incidence calculated in this study (Figure 2b) ranged from 0.69 in 2008 to 3.03 in 1998. However, the value for 2008 may be artificially low due to incomplete data for that year. With regard to seasonality, when comparing Figure 2a and c it is clear that a higher number of cases occurred during the wet season, although only a weak positive correlation between monthly rainfall and incidence was found (r 2 = 0.47, significant at the 95% confidence level) (Figure 2d). A likely cause of this weak relationship is the influence of other factors in leptospirosis occurrence.
When data were disaggregated to the community level, the community with highest number of observed CC found was Sangre Grande, the location of which is indicated on Figure 3a. Following Equation (1), the Standardized Incidence Ratio for each community (SIR i ) was calculated and is mapped in Figure 3b. While there appears to be a general trend for higher numbers of leptospirosis cases in the north-east, the overall geographical pattern is not clear. As indicated above, this is likely to be because of the low numbers of cases in many communities. The kernel map in Figure 3c shows a smoothed geographical distribution of leptospirosis cases and facilitates the visualization of patterns across the communities. Low rates (below 1) are mostly seen in the south-west of the island; high rates (above 1) occur in the north-east and indicate areas where leptospirosis occurrence is higher than the average expected value given the community population size. The kernel map therefore allows us to infer that leptospirosis may present a geographically variable pattern with the highest incidence around the rural area of the Regional Corparation of Sangre Grande, including the communities Guaico, Valencia, Oropuche, Cumuto, Turure, Wallerfield and Arima. Further, the high pseudo t-values (|t| > 1.96) plotted as contour lines on Figure 3c indicate that this pattern may be statistically significant, particularly in the north-east.
GPR and GWPR model results
Prior to the development of GPR and GWPR models, multicollinearity was assessed for all covariates. The condition numbers provided by the test results ranged from 19.25 in the central north communities to 27.88 in the far southwest ones. As all condition numbers were less than 30, these results indicate that multicollinearity was not a problem among the covariates.
Summary of global Poisson regression model parameter estimates and pseudo t -values statistics
Parameter estimate (β k )
t-value (β k /Se(β k ))
Summary of global (GPR) and local (GWPR) models statistics for model comparisons
% Deviance explained
Diff of criterion
2.GWPR (all covariates)*
3. WETINDEX, SOILIMPD, RAINMEAN
4. WETINDEX, SOILIMPD
5. WETINDEX, SOILIMPD, RIVRDENS
Next, a series of additional GWPR models were developed, in which all possible combinations of the five total hydrological covariates were used to explore the behavior of covariates on model performance (30 models in total, each with between 1 and 4 covariates). The model with the smallest AICc value (392.46) (Table 3, model 3), was selected as the model that better fitted the observed data. For model selection we followed the criteria of the minimum AIC estimator (MAICE) (i.e., the model with optimal bandwidth) where the model with the smallest AIC is selected (Nakaya et al. 2005; Jarup et al. 2002). The model selected included rainfall, topographic wetness index and the percentage of imperfect/ impeded soil and had an AICc value around 3 lower than the full GWPR model, indicating that there may be a substantive difference in the performance of the two models. In addition, the optimal bandwidth decreased from 42.8 to 33.1 km. As bandwidth increases, a GWPR model is likely to tend towards the GPR model due to increased smoothing of weights given to data points. In addition, estimates may become biased due to the increasing distances of data from the regression point (Fotheringham et al. 2002). Conversely, for smaller bandwidths, parameter estimates will depend increasingly on observations in proximity to the regression point i, and their variance will increase (Charlton et al. 2005). This decrease in bandwidth, combined with an improved value for AICc, indicates a further divergence from the GPR model to one in which spatially variable relationships are important.
In Figure 5b the majority of the odds ratios for soil with imperfect/impeded drainage are less than one, indicating that as the proportion of soil with imperfect/impeded drainage increases, leptospirosis decreases, particularly in the south. Although this is counter-intuitive, the relationship as indicated by the pseudo t-values is very weak. As will be explored in further detail below, this may be due the influence of other covariates on the parameter estimates of soil with imperfect/impeded drainage.
In Figure 5c the odds ratio of the topographic wetness index are shown. As with the rainfall, all values of the odds ratios are above one, indicating that as wetness index increases, so does leptospirosis. Conversely to rainfall, however, the strongest relationship is in the south. Although the reasons for this trend are not clear, since rainfall tends to be lower in the south and west (Figure 4a), a possible explanation may be that the topographic wetness index is proportionally more important in these locations since it indicates the accumulation of water which is necessary for leptospires to survive in the environment. The pseudo t-values showed a strong relationship for all communities.
As described above, soil with imperfect/impeded drainage was not significant when rainfall was included as a covariate in the model, but once rainfall was removed from the model, the relationship in the north became locally significant. From this, we infer that soil with imperfect/impeded drainage may be a relevant factor for leptospirosis occurrence. Although the models showed that rainfall is clearly important to the occurrence of leptospirosis, when this covariate was not included in further models, the underlying relationships between other covariates and leptospirosis became clearer. In the statistical model, it appears that rainfall dominates the other, more localized effects of other hydrological covariates such as soil drainage and topographic wetness index, indicated by the reduction in the bandwidth observed when it was excluded and the increases in pseudo t-values. Soil drainage and wetness index are clearly local conditions which make the disease appear to be stronger in some communities. Using GWPR we were able to explore the spatial heterogeneity of human leptospirosis and its underlying related hydrological factors. This would not be possible using only global models, which do not account for this variability. In addition, global models which spatially average are contrary to the common purpose of disease studies which aim to identify important local clusters of disease occurrence (Fotheringham et al. 2002).
The results shown in the kernel map and predicted cases (Figures 3c and 6) presented a common pattern of expected and predicted leptospirosis risk for the north east of Trinidad, more specifically, for Sangre Grande and the surrounding communities. Parameter estimates for hydrological covariates such imperfect/impeded soil drainage and wetness index reveal interesting patterns towards the northern part of Trinidad (Figure 6). These results may suggest the existence of an important cluster of leptospirosis related to the local hydrology of this area which requires further and more detailed analysis. The findings regarding a possible cluster in the Sangre Grande surrounding area, a predominantly agricultural region, may also suggest that leptospirosis in Trinidad could be related to rural areas.
Although hydrologic factors are clearly influencing human leptospirosis in Trinidad, we must acknowledge the importance of other aspects such as socio-economic, demographic and additional environmental indicators and it is possible that these other factors may be confounders for the observed relationships, something which requires further investigation. The ecology of leptospirosis is highly complex and, in the attempt to contribute to its explanation in the Caribbean region, in this paper we only explored one important facet of it. In future work, the interaction among multiple types of covariates and their influence on human leptospirosis should be explored. To date, no similar modeling studies have been developed in the country.
Kernel mapping analysis allowed us to reveal the existence of geographical patterns of leptospirosis across Trinidad, where low rates (below 1) were found in the south-west communities and high rates (above 1) occurred in the north-east. The highest leptospirosis incidence was found in the rural area of the Regional Corparation of Sangre Grande, including the communities Guaico, Valencia, Oropuche, Cumuto, Turure, Wallerfield and Arima. To support these findings, pseudo t-values (Figure 3c) indicated that this pattern may be statistically significant, particularly in the north-east.
For the global analysis using GPR, rainfall (RAINMEAN) and the topographic wetness index (WETINDEX) were both found to be statistically significant (|t| > 1.96) at the 95% confidence level), with t values of 5.8 and 6.2, respectively. However, since this was a global model, it did not help to understand if spatial variability exists in the relationship of leptospirosis and hydrological factors. Improvement of the local (GWPR) over the global (GPR) models results, indicated by AICc and percentage of deviance explained, suggests that GWPR models explained better the relationship between hydrological factors and leptospirosis. In practice, if the difference between AICc values of two models is less or equal to two, there is no significant difference in the performance of them (Cheng et al. 2011). In this way, the existence of spatial heterogeneity in the relationship was also demonstrated. The model which included rainfall, topographic wetness index and the percentage of soil with imperfect/ impeded drainage was selected as best fitting the observed data, from which we conclude that these three factors are to some extent important for leptospirosis throughout Trinidad communities. Odds ratio and pseudo t-values of these parameter estimates also demonstrated spatial heterogeneity across the island.
Stronger underlying local relationships were also revealed when rainfall was excluded from the model. Throughout the exploration of the data an interesting human leptospirosis cluster was found. Thus, GWPR was also used as a spatial analysis technique to reveal important underlying geographical patterns in the association of human leptospirosis with local hydrological dynamics (Nakaya et al. 2005).
Based on the accuracy of predictions obtained from the analysis of observed cases in each community () and the residuals we can conclude that GWPR is useful as an exploratory tool for the identification of areas at risk as well as for the study of the risk of misdiagnosed, under reported, or neglected disease with a high environmental component, such as leptospirosis. While we acknowledge the multifactorial causes of leptospirosis, here we have used GWPR to indicate the important influence of local hydrological dynamics on human leptospirosis in Trinidad. However, it is important to note that ecological studies such as this one are not able to assign causation and, as such, more research is required to investigate the covariates identified as they relate to leptospirosis (e.g. using a case–control study). Additionally, seasonality in relationships should be assessed at a localized level. In this study it was not possible since insufficient data were available to allow the level of disaggregation required.
We hope that the research presented in this paper provides useful guidance for the development of more detailed studies. We took a multidisciplinary, integrated approach to the study of a disease of public health importance, strongly related to the environment. In order to find appropriate solutions to these issues, future research should consider a holistic approach for their study, looking at diseases associated with the environment as multifactorial problems rather than in isolation.
We would like to thank Dr Avery Hinds and all the members of the Surveillance Unit of the Ministry of Health of Trinidad & Tobago for their help and support in gathering the Leptospirosis data. The software of GWR4 used in this paper is available at: http://gwr.nuim.ie/.
PhD research has been funded by a scholarship from the University of the West Indies. MCV would like to thank Dr Matthew Wilson for his constructive comments on drafts of the manuscript.
Responsible editor: Michael Piasecki
- Adler B, de la Peña Monctezuma A: Leptospira and leptospirosis. Vet microbiol 2010, 140: 287–296. 10.1016/j.vetmic.2009.03.012View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Amilasan AT, Ujiie M, Suzuki M, Salva E, Belo MCP, Belo MCP, Koizumi N, Yoshimatsu K, Schmidt WP, Marte S, Dimaano EM, Villarama JB, Ariyos K: Outbreak of Leptospirosis after Flood, the Philippines. Emerg Infect Dis 2009, 18: 91–94.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Barcellos C, Sabroza PC: The place behind the case: leptospirosis risks and associated environmental conditions in a flood-related outbreak in Rio de Janeiro. Cad Saude Publica 2001, 17(Suppl):59–67.Google Scholar
- Beniamino C, Ciceroni L, Maffei C, Distanislao F, Strusi P, Calegari L, Lupidi R, Scalise G, Cagnoni G, Renga G: A Waterborne Outbreak of Leptospirosis. Am J Epidemiol 1987, 126: 535–545.Google Scholar
- Best N, Ickstant K, Wolpert R: Spatial Poisson regression for health and exposure data measured at disparate resolutions. J Am Stat Assoc 2000, 95: 1076–1088. 10.1080/01621459.2000.10474304View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beven KJ, Kirby MJ: A physically based, variable contributing area model of basin hydrology. Hydrolog Sci B 1979, 24: 43–69.Google Scholar
- Bharti AR, Nally JE, Ricaldi JN, Matthias MA, Diaz MM, Lovett MA, Willing MR, Gotuzzo E, Vinetz JM: Leptospirosis : a zoonotic disease of global importance. The Lancet Infect Dis 2003, 3: 757–771. 10.1016/S1473-3099(03)00830-2View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Brown CB, Bally GS: Land Capability Survey of Trinidad and Tobago No. 4: Soils of Central Trinidad. Trinidad: The Government of Trinidad and Tobago, The University of the West Indies, Texaco Oil Company, Shell Trinidad Limited, Tate and Lyle (Caroni Limited), British Petroleum (Trinidad) Limited; 1970a:1–142.Google Scholar
- Brown CB, Bally GS: Land Capability Survey of Trinidad and Tobago No. 5: Soils of Central Trinidad. Trinidad: The Government of Trinidad and Tobago, The University of the West Indies, Texaco Oil Company, Shell Trinidad Limited, Tate and Lyle (Caroni Limited), British Petroleum (Trinidad) Limited; 1970b:1–145.Google Scholar
- Caribbean Epidemiology Center: A Caribbean Communicable Disease Surveillance Manual for Public Health Action. Trinidad: Caribbean Epidemiology Center; 1999.Google Scholar
- Caribbean Epidemiology Center: Annual Report. Trinidad: Caribbean Epidemiology Center; 2009.Google Scholar
- Caribbean Epidemiology Center: Annual Report. Trinidad: Caribbean Epidemiology Center; 2010.Google Scholar
- Caribbean Epidemiology Center: Annual Report. Trinidad: Caribbean Epidemiology Center; 2011.Google Scholar
- Charlton M, Fortheringham S, Brunsdon C: Geographically Weighted Regression, ESRC National Centre for Research Methods, NCRM Methods Review Papers 2005, NCRM/006. University of Southampton, Southampton: ESRC National Centre for Research Methods; 2005.Google Scholar
- Cheng EM, Atkinson PM, Shahani AK: Elucidating the spatially varying relation between cervical cancer and socio-economic conditions in England. Int J Health Geogr 2011, 10: 51. 10.1186/1476-072X-10-51View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- CSO: Trinidad and Tobago 2011 Population and Housing Census Demographic Report. Central Statistical Office, Ministry of Planning and Development, Government of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago; 2012. [http://www.cso.gov.tt/sites/default/files/content/images/census/TRINIDAD%20AND%20TOBAGO%202011%20Demographic%20Report.pdf] Google Scholar
- Cummingham RK, Vlitos AJ, Spector J, Brown CB: Land Capability Survey of Trinidad and Tobago No. 5: Soils of Northem Trinidad. Trinidad: The Government of Trinidad and Tobago, The University of the West Indies, Texaco Oil Company, Shell Trinidad Limited, Tate and Lyle (Caroni Limited), British Petroleum (Trinidad) Limited; 1970:1–140.Google Scholar
- De US, Dube RK, Prakasa Rao GS: Extreme Weather Events over India in the last 100 years. J Ind Geophy. Un 2005, 9: 173–187.Google Scholar
- Dechet AM, Parsons M, Rambaran M, Mohamed-Rambaran P, Florendo-Cumbermack A, Persaud S, Baboolal S, Ari MD, Shadomy SV, Zaki SR, Paddock CD, Clark TA, Harris L, Lyon D, Mintz ED: Leptospirosis Outbreak following Severe Flooding: A Rapid Assessment and Mass Prophylaxis Campaign: Guyana, January–February 2005. PLoS ONE 2012, 7: e39672. 10.1371/journal.pone.0039672View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fotheringham A, Brunsdon C, Charlton M: Geographically weighted regression: the analysis of the spatially varying relationships. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons; 2002.Google Scholar
- Gaynor K, Katz AR, Park SY, Nakata M, Clark TA, Effler PV: Leptospirosis on Oahu: an outbreak associated with flooding of a university campus. Am J Trop Med Hyg 2007, 76: 882–885.Google Scholar
- Henry RA, Johnson RC: Distribution of the genus leptospira in soil and water. Appl Environ Microbiol 1978, 35: 492–499.Google Scholar
- Jarup L, Best N, Toledano MB, Wakefield J, Elliott P: Geographical epidemiology of prostate cancer in Great Britain. Int J Cancer 2002, 97: 695–699. 10.1002/ijc.10113View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jena AB, Mohanty KC, Devadasan N: An outbreak of leptospirosis in Orissa, India: the importance of surveillance. Trop Med Int Health 2004, 9: 1016–1021. 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2004.01293.xView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kalashnikov IA, Mezentsev VM, Mkrtchan MO, Grizhebovskii GM, Briukhanova GD: Features of leptospirosis in the Krasnodar Territory. Zh Mikrobiol Epidemiol Immunobiol 2003, 6: 68–71.Google Scholar
- Keith W: Leptospirosis associated with outbreak of acute febrile illness and pulmonary haemorrhage, Nicaragua, 1995. Lancet 1996, 347: 535–536. 10.1016/S0140-6736(96)91167-8View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lau C, Smythe L, Weinstein P: Leptospirosis: an emerging disease in travellers. Travel Med Infect Dis 2010, 8: 33–39. 10.1016/j.tmaid.2009.12.002View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lau CL, Smythe LD, Craig SB, Weinstein P: Climate change, flooding, urbanisation and leptospirosis: fuelling the fire? Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 2010, 104: 631–638. 10.1016/j.trstmh.2010.07.002View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lau CL, Clements AC, Skelly C, Dobson AJ, Smythe LD, Weinstein PS: Leptospirosis in American Samoa – Estimating and Mapping Risk Using Environmental Data. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2012, 6: e1669. 10.1371/journal.pntd.0001669View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Levett P: Leptospirosis. Clin Microbiol Rev 2001, 14: 296–326. 10.1128/CMR.14.2.296-326.2001View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lovett A, Flowerdew R: analysis of count data using Poisson regression. Prof Geogr 1989, 41: 190–198. 10.1111/j.0033-0124.1989.00190.xView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Maciel EAP, de Carvalho ALF, Nascimento SF, de Matos RB, Gouveia EL, Reis MG, Ko AI: Household Transmission of Leptospira Infection in Urban Slum Communities. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2008, 2: e154. 10.1371/journal.pntd.0000154View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mahajan S, Chlabra D: Leptospirosis: A Re-emerging Disease. Vet World 2008, 1: 182–185.Google Scholar
- Michel V, Branger C, Andre-Fontaine G: Epidemiology of leptospirosis. Rev Cub Med Trop 2002, 54: 7–10.Google Scholar
- Min SK, Zhang X, Zwiers FW, Heg GC: Human contribution to more-intense precipitation extremes. Nature 2011, 470: 378–381. 10.1038/nature09763View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mohan ARM, Cumberbatch A, Adesiyun A, Chadee DD: Epidemiology of human leptospirosis in Trinidad and Tobago, 1996–2007: a retrospective study. Acta tropica 2009, 112: 260–265. 10.1016/j.actatropica.2009.08.007View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nakaya T, Fotheringham AS, Brunsdon C, Charlton M: Geographically weighted Poisson regression for disease association mapping. Stat Med 2005, 24: 2695–2717. 10.1002/sim.2129View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Naranjo M, Suárez M, Fernández C, Amador N, González M, Batista N, González I, Valdez Y, Infante JF, Sierra G: Study of a Leptospirosis Outbreak in Honduras Following Hurricane Mitch and Prophylactic Protection of the vax-SPIRAL® Vaccine. MEDICC Rev 2008, 10: 38–42.Google Scholar
- Quinn PF, Beven KJ, Lamb R: The ln( a /tan β ) index : how to calculate it a n d how to use it within the topmodel framework. Hydrol Process 1995, 9: 161–182. 10.1002/hyp.3360090204View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Saito M, Villanueva SYAM, Antara C, Miyahara S, Segawa T, Asoh T, Ozuru R, Gloriani NG, Yanagihara Y, Yoshida S: Comparative Analysis of Leptospira Strains Isolated from Environmental Soil and Water in the Philippines and Japan. Appl Environ Microbiol 2013, 79: 601–609. 10.1128/AEM.02728–12 10.1128/AEM.02728-12 10.1128/AEM.02728-12View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sanders EJ, Rigau-Pérez JG, Smits HL, Deseda CC, Vorndam V, Aye T, Spiegel R, Weyant RS, Bragg SL: Increase of leptospirosis in dengue-negative patients after a hurricane in Puerto Rico in 1996. Am J Trop Med Hyg 1999, 61: 399–404.Google Scholar
- Segura ER, Ganoza CA, Campos K, Ricaldi JN, Torres S, Silva H, Céspedes MJ, Matthias MA, Swancutt MA, López Liñán R, Gotuzzo E, Guerra H, Gilman RH, Vinetz JM: Clinical spectrum of pulmonary involvement in leptospirosis in a region of endemicity, with quantification of leptospiral burden. Clin Infect Dis 2005, 40(3):343–351. 10.1086/427110View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sehgal SC, Sugunan AP, Vijayachari P: Outbreak of leptospirosis after the cyclone in Orissa. Natl Med J India 2002, 15: 22–23.Google Scholar
- Sejvar J, Bancroft E, Winthrop K, Bettinger J, Bajani M, Bragg S, Shutt K, Kaiser R, Marano N, Popovic T, Tappero J, Ashford D, Mascola L, Vugia D, Perkins B, Rosenstein N: Leptospirosis in “Eco-Challenge”Athletes, Malaysian Borneo 2000. Emerg Infect Dis 2003, 9: 702–707. 10.3201/eid0906.020751View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Smythe L, Barnett L, Symonds M, Dohnt M, Baade P, McClintock C, et al.: An outbreak of leptospirosis in North Queensland, Australia January to May, 1999. Technology 2002, 9: 15–22.Google Scholar
- Stern EJ, Galloway R, Shadomy SV, Wannemuehler K, Atrubin D, Blackmore C, Wofford T, Wilkins PP, Ari MD, Harris L, Clark TA: Outbreak of leptospirosis among Adventure Race participants in Florida, 2005. Clin Infect Dis 2010, 50: 843–849. 10.1086/650578View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Vanasco NB, Schmeling MF, Lottersberger J, Costa F, Ko AI, Tarabla HD: Clinical characteristics and risk factors of human leptospirosis in Argentina (1999–2005). Acta Trop 2008, 107: 255–258. 10.1016/j.actatropica.2008.06.007View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Vijayachari P, Sehgal SC, Goris MG, Terpstra WJ, Hartskeerl RA: Leptospira interrogans serovar Valbuzzi: a cause of severe pulmonary haemorrhages in the Andaman Islands. J Med Microbiol 2003, 52: 913–918. 10.1099/jmm.0.05094-0View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Vinetz JM, Wilcox BA, Aguirre A, Gollin LX, Katz AR, Fujioka RS, Maly K, Horwitz P, Chang H: Beyond Disciplinary Boundaries: Leptospirosis as a Model of Incorporating Transdisciplinary Approaches to Understand Infectious Disease Emergence. Eco Health 2005, 2: 291–306.Google Scholar
- Waller LA, Gotway CA: Applied Spatial Statistics for Public Health Data. New Jersey: Wiley; 2004.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Watson JT, Gayer M, Connolly MA: Epidemics after natural disasters. Emerg Infect Dis 2007, 13: 1–5. 10.3201/eid1301.060779View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wilcox B, Colwell RR: Emerging and Reemerging Infectious Diseases: Biocomplexity as an Interdisciplinary Paradigm. Ecohealth 2005, 2: 244–257. 10.1007/s10393-005-8961-3View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- World Health Organization: Human leptospirosis : Guidance for Diagnosis, Surveillance and Control. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2003.Google Scholar
- World Health Organization: Report of the second meeting of the leptospirosis burden epidemiology reference group. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2011.Google Scholar
- Zaki SR, Shieh WJ: Leptospirosis associated with outbreak of acute febrile illness and pulmonary haemorrhage, Nicaragua, 1995. Lancet 1996, 347: 535–536. 10.1016/S0140-6736(96)91167-8View ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.